Our annual cider meeting was hosted this November by Andy T. at his home in Trumbull. As is typical of a meeting hosted by Andy, the spread was outstanding, including homemade bread, a number of delicious cheeses (sourced from the newly opened Aldi in Trumbull), and much more. We first spent time together over food and drinks, sharing updates on our lives and plans for the coming holiday season. Andy C. and Pierre also shared that they had attended the “Fermentis Academy” at Two Roads earlier in the day, learning a ton about yeast (and getting to sample some spirits courtesy of Phil).
As we moved on to the tasting portion of the night, we got to enjoy a wide variety of delicious ciders, including some quite strong ice ciders that Andy generously shared from his cellar. Paul H. shared that he would be judging in Cider Days up in Massachusetts, and encouraged members to submit their entries. Since I’m so late getting around to writing this post, I can share that our club was very well represented in the awards, with Paul B-S. taking home a gold, silver, and bronze, and Pierre grabbing a bronze as well. Congratulations!
Tasting Notes:
- New World Cider (C1A): Steve V. – Very subtle, bright apple, red apple, apple peel, v. light stone fruit. Lovely appearance, very clear if not brilliant. Clean, fresh. Fine bubbles. Very refreshing, crisp. Nothing off. Good tannin balance, . Light astringency supports balance. Great apple quality. Flavorful without being in your face. Nice dry finish.
8/6/20/8 = 42 (2023 Beardsley, pectic enzyme, yeast nutrient) - New World Cider (C1A) – Something like yeast-autolysis… light smoke, “meaty” – light burnt rubber. Very light color – first pours were completely clear, very hazy towards the end. Don’t need to score this… it’s a 7.5 year old cider given to Andy T. by Steve V. – “He did this to me once!”
- New World Cider (C1A): Paul B-S – Called it an “American Cider” – fresh apple, tough of sulfur, crisp green apple, bruised/cooked apple. a light spice note on the finish. If you told us it’s a dry hopped cider, we’d believe you. Something there. Could be clearer. Alcohol is noticeable. Very nice, long dry finish. Baked apple, apple crisp. Acidity is there – high-ish, sharp, but not too much. Balanced out with the tannins. In a perfect world, less dry in the finish. Overall, really nice. A substantial drink. Shares a lot with white wine.
7/5/19/8 = 39 (Beardsley 2022, “I was there late…” maybe it was what settled and was stronger than others as a result. Not fortified. Mangrove Jack ale yeast [Empire]. - New World Cider (C1A): Steve V. – Cranberry, apple, crab apple, cherry. Something in there. A little funk in there… hay/barnyard… complex. Orchard vibes. Gorgeous. Clear. Consistent. Like a rosé. Pink/red. Strong acidity, again giving cranberry vibes. Tart. Not very high on tannins… would like more balance between tannins and acidity. Does feel dry on the palate across the finish. Astringency maybe a touch high. Would be beautiful with food – maybe not as much as a whole pint on its own.
8/6/18/7 = 39 (Redfield apples, single varietal. Red fleshed. 2023.) - New World Cider (C1A): Steve V. – Blend of Redfield and Beardsley – light fresh melon, very subtle aroma. Light fruit salad. Lovely aroma. Full marks for appearance, clear through the pour. Lingering dryness without harshness. Bright apple, clean, snappy apple character. Tastes like apples. Nice acidity. Enough sweetness to carry. Balance is fantastic. I would drink this all day every day. The glass is too damn small.
8/6/24/9 = 47 (blended directly from the kegs. 25% Redfield, 75% Beardsley heirloom. Force carbonated in PET bottle.) - New World Cider (C1A): Paul B-S – Wild yeast, 7.8%, v. Bubbly – very fruity, a little harshness (touch of acetone/solvent). Smells wild, mostly from top pours. Bottom pours have more apple in the aroma. Baked apple. As an English cider, the aroma seems more appropriate… more apple-adjacent than really smelling like apples. Nice, slightly cloudy. Not hazy. Not particularly wild flavor. Very tannic. Has a little funk that you’d attribute more to English style. As a new world, a little bitter. Overall, it’s a bit of both… but leaning more towards English.
As a New World: 6/5/16/6 = 33 | As an English Cider: 8/6/20/8 = 42 (2023 Beardsley) - English Cider (C1B): Andy T. – sulphur, no real apple character, but that’s a good thing. It smells like cider, slightly sweet, slightly alcoholic… a little funk a little heat. Crystal clear. Gorgeous. Light golden. Quite sharp, and quite funky. Tart/acidity. Plenty of tannin, lingers forever. Not astringent. Alcohol more present on the flavor (and aroma) than maybe it should be. Very drinkable.
7/6/18/8 = 39 - New England Cider: Paul B-S – 16% – it smells like an ice cider. Carmel apple. A touch of molasses. Could be a little oxidized. Sherry. Lovely aroma. A touch more than still. Rich golden caramel. Surprisingly sweet but dry in the finish. The alcohol really carries that though. Missing some acidity. Caramel apple – or caramelized apple. Quite sweet. Cherry pit/vanilla. Some sharpness on the finish. Very easy to drink for what it is! More refreshing than expected given all that sugar. “I could get really hurt on this” – Paul H.
10/6/23/10 = 49 (maple! Beardsley cider, fermented wild for a while… added 2# raisins, 1 gal maple syrup, and wine yeast) - Cider with Other Fruit (C2B): Pierre M. – very fruity, but not apple. Not weird bad, just weird. Shredded, untoasted coconut. Goes right up to the line of suntan lotion without going over the edge. Very fresh cider. Looks like cider. Cider with coconut. Who knew apple and coconut melded so well? Doesn’t overwhelm the apple at all. The balance is just great. Tannin is so much there without being astringent. All over the palate on the finish. This is absolutely lovely. Delicious and refreshing. So unique and balanced.
9/6/24/10 – 49 (Pierre – “I’m not revealing my secrets”)
[photos not included… someday your Communications Guru will remember to pull out his phone for something other than notes and style guidelines, sorry!]